Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (2024)

When you think of eyeshadow primer, perhaps you don’t feel the same level of excitement as you would about an incredible mascara, a holy grail liquid foundation, or the perfect nude lipstick. But the value of a great eyeshadow primer cannot be overstated. It’s often the key to a smooth, vibrant, long-lasting eye makeup look, and if you ask us, it’s a makeup bag staple.

But just like other makeup categories, the best eyeshadow primer for you depends on your wants and needs. So, we put almost 30 to the test in The Lab, and ahead, we’re sharing which ones performed the best. From lightweight formulas and budget-friendly options to color-correcting primers and more, we’ve got you covered.

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review

Best for Brightening:

ILIA Eye Primer at Amazon$24

Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review

What We Like

  • Lightweight texture

  • Smoothing feel

  • Budge-proof

What to Consider

  • Handle applicator is a bit long which makes precise application tricky

Shades: 2 | Translucent: Yes | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: No

The brand is arguably most known for its award-winning complexion products, but we believe this eyeshadow primer from NARS deserves more attention. The thin, lightweight consistency blends onto the eyelids with ease to create a smooth, soft canvas for eyeshadow. While the original shade is completely transparent making it an excellent choice for all skin tones, the shade Light has a slight beige color to it which can help blur the appearance of veins on the eyelids.

Katherine, NARS tester: “The primer was very easy to blend in and felt weightless on my eyelid.”

What We Like

  • Smooth texture

  • Contains a lot of product

  • Very blendable

What to Consider

  • Doesn’t come with an applicator

Shades: 1 | Translucent: Yes | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If you’re thinking that this is a face primer, you’re right. But we don’t always play by the rules, and you don’t have to either. It was formulated to be a matte primer for the face, but the brand claims that it makes a great eyeshadow primer—and we agree. Our tester shared that the smooth, creamy texture blended over her eyelids easily and dried down quickly to a comfortable matte finish. Because of the matte finish and not overly emollient texture, it’s a great option for people with oily eyelids. We also love that it can be used on the face and eyes, helping to cut down on the amount of products you’ll need in your makeup collection.

  • Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (7)

  • Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (8)

  • Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (9)

  • Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (10)

What We Like

  • Provides even coverage

  • Peachy hue brightens the area

  • Comfortable dry-down

What to Consider

  • It wasn't the most longwearing

Shades: 1 | Translucent: No | Long-Lasting: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Discoloration on the eyelids is extremely common, but it can be super frustrating when creating an eyeshadow look. That’s why tinted eyeshadow primers, like this one, are great for people who have veins or hyperpigmentation in the area. Aside from the creamy consistency and the velvety, comfortable dry-down, our tester raved about the color of this primer. She explained that the peachy hue worked to brighten up the area while simultaneously providing enough coverage to effectively even out her eyelids. She also noted how much she appreciated the packaging design. Because the tube has one flat edge, it won’t roll around on your vanity and potentially break.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (12)

Caitlyn, Rare Beauty tester: “I can't get over how much I loved the color of this eyeshadow primer. It is a tinted peach color that immediately brightened up my eye area. It smoothed easily and provided consistent coverage across my entire eyelid.”

Best for Brightening

ILIA Eye Primer

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (13)

What We Like

  • Lightweight formula and feel on the skin

  • Fast-absorbing

  • Brightening finish

What to Consider

  • It caused a slight burning sensation upon initial application

Shade Range: 1 | Translucent: Yes | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Sure, eyeshadow primers are meant to serve as a base for makeup and help to increase the longevity of your look, but why not throw other benefits in there too? This primer has a subtle pearlescence to it which gives the eyelids a brighter, more light-reflective look. It even looks pretty alone on the lids. But don’t worry, you can still apply matte shadows on top and achieve your desired finish. The lightweight texture and fast absorption were what stood out most to our tester, and she also noted that once dry, she couldn’t feel it sitting on her eyelids.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (14)

What We Like

  • Easy to blend

  • Camouflages discoloration

  • Budge-proof

What to Consider

  • Limited shade range

Shades: 1 | Translucent: No | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

The great thing about tinted primers is that they can help to address discoloration while also providing an additional layer of color that can boost the vibrancy of the shadows you apply on top. This option has a creamy beige color that works to cancel out discoloration as well as make eyeshadows appear more vivid. While it can certainly be used on all skin tones to up the intensity of whatever eyeshadow is applied on top, we would love to see the brand release more shades so that people can more closely match their skin tones if they desire. Aside from the even coverage it provides, our tester loved the silky texture and the quick-drying formula.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (16)

What We Like

  • Weightless feel on the skin

  • Doe foot applicator makes application easy

  • Great for oily lids

What to Consider

  • Some reviewers say it dries down too matte

Shades: 1 | Translucent: Semi | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

The feeling of heavy product sitting on the skin is a makeup pet peeve for many, but with this ultra-lightweight product, you won’t have to worry about that. The formula is soft and airy to the touch, and it blends across the eyelids with almost no effort required. Our tester shared that the doe foot applicator made for a mess-free application, and once applied, she couldn’t tell that there was product on her eyelids. She also noted that while the primer has a milky, off-white color out of the tube, it dries down to a colorless finish on the lids.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (18)

What We Like

  • Not overly pigmented

  • Budge-proof

  • Easy to apply

What to Consider

  • Only comes in one shade

Shades: 1 | Translucent: No | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: No

This tinted primer works to cancel out discoloration on the eyelids while enhancing the vibrancy of your eyeshadow, and most importantly, keeps your look locked in for the long haul. If you need your makeup to stay put for a special occasion, this is a solid choice. Our tester explained that she appreciated the level of pigmentation because while it doesn’t completely blank out the eyelids, it does provide enough coverage to create a pretty even canvas. Because it’s not full coverage, the shade is flexible and works for a variety of skin tones. However, we do think that adding one lighter shade and one deeper shade to the lineup would be ideal.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (20)

Shannon, Benefit tester: “It felt really creamy to apply, but once it dried it was set. It didn't crease, smudge, or move. It felt super lightweight on the eye too."

What We Like

  • Smooth, lightweight texture

  • Dries down quickly

  • Great for oily lids

What to Consider

  • Tint dissipates on the lids

Shades: 6 | Translucent: Semi | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: No

If you have oily lids or you live in a rainy, humid climate, chances are a water-resistant eyeshadow primer could save you from some makeup mishaps. In addition to being water-resistant and crease-proof, it has a light, creamy texture that glides onto the lids with ease. Our tester appreciated how easy it was to apply and how it dried down quickly to a comfortable finish. She shared that she couldn’t feel it sitting on her lids, and her eyeshadow applied smoothly over it and stayed in place.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (22)

Lauren, Laura Mercier tester: “The primer felt smooth and lightweight. The product dried quickly, and I felt like I wasn't wearing anything.”

What We Like

  • Lightweight, even texture

  • Visibly enhanced the vibrancy of eyeshadow applied on top

What to Consider

  • This won't conceal veins, discoloration of the lid

Shades: 1 | Translucent: Yes | Long-Lasting: Yes | Cruelty-Free: No

If you’re looking for an affordable product to keep your eyeshadow locked in while intensifying the color payoff, you can’t go wrong with this colorless primer. The thin, transparent formula blends across the eyelids smoothly before drying down to a soft matte finish. Our tester appreciated the even consistency and the fact that it dried down quickly, but what sold her was that she saw a noticeable difference in the color payoff of her eyeshadow when applied on top of the primer.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (24)

Michelle, Ruby Kisses tester: “There were no creases or smudging and it was invisible on the lid under the eyeshadow. It helped the eyeshadow color stand out and appear brighter and more pigmented.”

What We Like

  • Angled applicator makes precision easy

  • Lightweight, creamy consistency

What to Consider

  • Some testers still experienced a bit of creasing

Shades: 1 | Translucent: Yes | Long-Lasting: Somewhat | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Products that can be used in multiple ways always earn extra points in our book, and this eyeshadow and concealer primer is no exception. It can be used to prep the eyelids for eyeshadow as well as prevent your concealer from creasing under your eyes, which if you’re like us, is a major makeup annoyance. The vegan formula contains hyaluronic acid to boost moisture, and the thin, transparent texture has a creamy texture that feels incredibly airy on the skin. In addition to the weightless feel on the eyelids, our tester shared that the angled applicator made applying the product in hard-to-reach areas simple.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (26)

What To Look For When Buying An Eyeshadow Primer

  • Coverage: By now you’re probably aware that some eyeshadow primers are completely transparent while others are slightly tinted or even quite pigmented. The right one for you depends on your goals. If you have discoloration on your eyelids that you’re hoping to cover, opt for a primer with coverage. Pigmented primers are also great if you’re hoping to create a full-glam look because they can help to boost the vibrancy of the eyeshadows you apply on top. But if you don’t have discoloration that you’re trying to cover, and you’re simply looking for a primer to act as a smooth canvas for shadow and keep it locked in place, a colorless option is a great choice.
  • Texture: Don’t underestimate the importance of texture when you’re trying to find the right eyeshadow primer for you. If you have dry eyelids, opting for a creamy primer is your best bet. But if you have oily lids, one with a more matte texture will suit your needs more.

FAQ

  • How do you apply eyeshadow primer?

    Like with most makeup products, the application method is up to you. You can blend eyeshadow primer across your eyelids with your fingertips or a brush, just be sure to blend it evenly and cover all of the areas where eyeshadow will be applied.

Why Trust Byrdie

Alyssa Kaplan is an experienced writer in the beauty industry and product tester specializing in cosmetics. She has tested dozens of eyeshadow primers over the years—including several on this list. Alyssa has been a commerce writer at Byrdie since 2022, where she covers all things beauty.

Goodbye Creased Eyeshadow—These 10 Eyeshadow Primers Were Winners in Our Testing (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Last Updated:

Views: 6119

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Birthday: 1992-06-28

Address: Apt. 413 8275 Mueller Overpass, South Magnolia, IA 99527-6023

Phone: +6824704719725

Job: District Real-Estate Facilitator

Hobby: Letterboxing, Vacation, Poi, Homebrewing, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Mrs. Angelic Larkin, I am a cute, charming, funny, determined, inexpensive, joyous, cheerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.